Skip to content
NoKYCScore
/
Submit a service

Lightning Loop vs Maya Protocol

It is a trade-off. Lightning Loop has the higher Safety grade (8.0 against 7.0), while Maya Protocol has the higher Privacy grade (8.5 against 7.8).

Lightning Loop

Lightning Labs' non-custodial submarine swap service for moving sats between Lightning and on-chain

Privacy

7.8/ 10

Strong

Safety

8.0/ 10

Strong

No ID mentioned KYC 1 Docs reviewed Full review →

Maya Protocol

THORChain-style cross-chain liquidity protocol with native BTC, ZEC and DASH pools

Privacy

8.5/ 10

Excellent

Safety

7.0/ 10

Strong

ID never required KYC 0 Docs reviewed Full review →

Side by side

Lightning LoopMaya Protocol
Category Instant Swaps Instant Swaps
KYC policy No ID mentioned ID never required
Custody Non Custodial Non Custodial
Sign-up No account needed No account needed
Open source Yes Yes
Tor onion address No No
Coins BTC BTC, ETH, ZEC, DASH, ADA, RUNE, CACAO, ARB
Pay with Crypto, Lightning Crypto
Fees Loop service fee varying with on-chain conditions, plus on-chain and routing fees; 30,000-sat no-show prepayment on Loop Out Fixed outbound fee plus a dynamic liquidity (slip-based) fee, per the docs
Founded 2019 Not published
Incidents on record 0 0
Published tests (180 days) 0 0

Only Lightning Loop

Accepts Lightning5+ years operating

Both

No registrationNo email neededNo phone neededNon-custodialOpen source

Only Maya Protocol

Nothing distinct

Where they sit among instant swaps

2 2 4 4 6 6 8 8 10 10 PRIVATE AND SAFE SAFE, ASKS MORE PRIVATE, LESS PROVEN PRIVACY GRADE → SAFETY GRADE → GhostSwap Privacy 10.0 · Safety 8.4 Chainflip Privacy 7.1 · Safety 8.3 Lightning Loop Privacy 7.8 · Safety 8.0 Swap Market Privacy 9.3 · Safety 7.3 eigenwallet Privacy 8.9 · Safety 7.0 Maya Protocol Privacy 8.5 · Safety 7.0 Bitania Privacy 8.5 · Safety 6.4 Godex Privacy 7.6 · Safety 6.3 THORChain Privacy 8.5 · Safety 5.9 xchange.me Privacy 6.6 · Safety 5.9 NativeSwap Privacy 7.3 · Safety 5.5 BitcoinVN Privacy 5.6 · Safety 5.3 ETZ-Swap Privacy 7.5 · Safety 5.2 WizardSwap Privacy 8.2 · Safety 5.1 MoBit Exchange Privacy 7.9 · Safety 5.0 0trace Privacy 8.9 · Safety 4.9 Mistex Privacy 8.9 · Safety 4.9 omenswap Privacy 8.0 · Safety 4.7 NEAR Intents Privacy 6.4 · Safety 4.7 NeverKYC Privacy 7.1 · Safety 4.6 OctoSwap Privacy 6.9 · Safety 4.6 Pablo Cash Privacy 8.9 · Safety 4.3 SWAP.MY Privacy 8.3 · Safety 4.3 SilentSwap Privacy 5.9 · Safety 4.3 xchg Privacy 7.9 · Safety 4.0 StereoSwap Privacy 7.3 · Safety 4.0 PegasusSwap Privacy 7.2 · Safety 4.0 FuguSwap Privacy 7.0 · Safety 4.0 xmr2cex Privacy 8.4 · Safety 3.7 Wagyu Privacy 5.4 · Safety 3.7 n.exchange Privacy 3.1 · Safety 6.1 SideShift.ai Privacy 4.2 · Safety 5.9 Alfacash Privacy 2.4 · Safety 5.5 SimpleSwap Privacy 2.9 · Safety 5.0 FixedFloat Privacy 3.7 · Safety 4.8 Flyp.me Privacy 3.2 · Safety 4.8 Mine.exchange Privacy 2.7 · Safety 4.8 Swapuz Privacy 3.4 · Safety 4.7 AvanChange Privacy 2.4 · Safety 4.6 The Change Privacy 2.6 · Safety 4.5 CrystalTrade Privacy 2.0 · Safety 4.5 StealthEX Privacy 2.7 · Safety 4.4 Changelly Privacy 1.7 · Safety 4.4 Fswap Privacy 3.6 · Safety 4.0 ChangeHero Privacy 3.4 · Safety 4.0 ChangeNOW Privacy 2.7 · Safety 4.0 PLATOV Privacy 2.7 · Safety 4.0 CCE Cash Privacy 2.5 · Safety 4.0 Mchanger Privacy 2.4 · Safety 4.0 BitSwitch Privacy 4.0 · Safety 3.9 SecureShift Privacy 4.0 · Safety 3.9 Priamex Privacy 3.8 · Safety 3.9 Ninja.Exchange Privacy 3.6 · Safety 3.9 PulseLN Privacy 3.3 · Safety 3.9 ExWell Privacy 2.1 · Safety 3.9 Nanswap Privacy 3.2 · Safety 3.7 Exolix Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.7 HiddenSwap Privacy 3.4 · Safety 3.6 ChainSwap Privacy 3.0 · Safety 3.6 InstantExchangers Privacy 3.0 · Safety 3.6 Rabbit Swap Privacy 2.9 · Safety 3.6 YellowChanger Privacy 2.6 · Safety 3.6 AlwaysMoney Privacy 2.0 · Safety 3.6 BitcoinBox Privacy 2.0 · Safety 3.6 RubyCash Privacy 2.0 · Safety 3.6 BitFlaming Privacy 1.5 · Safety 3.6 XMRS Privacy 3.4 · Safety 3.4 Mix Swap Privacy 3.4 · Safety 3.3 Rebex Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.1 CoinCraddle Privacy 3.1 · Safety 3.0 GoExme Privacy 3.1 · Safety 3.0 SwapRocket Privacy 3.1 · Safety 3.0 BitXchange Privacy 3.0 · Safety 3.0 Baltex Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 Changee Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 EXC24 Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 Explace Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 Fujn Swap Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 SnapSwap Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 SwapGate Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 Swappix Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 Xgram.io Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 YBEX Privacy 2.7 · Safety 3.0 Expeer Privacy 2.4 · Safety 3.0 EasyBit Privacy 2.3 · Safety 3.0 CoinPayMaster Privacy 1.9 · Safety 3.0 Lizex Privacy 3.0 · Safety 1.5 Swapter Privacy 2.7 · Safety 0.1
Trade Spend Infrastructure Identity 88 services. Hover or tap a point.

Questions

Is Lightning Loop or Maya Protocol safer?

Lightning Loop has the higher Safety grade: Lightning Loop 8.0, Maya Protocol 7.0, out of 10.

Does Lightning Loop or Maya Protocol require KYC?

Lightning Loop is KYC level 1 (no ID mentioned). Maya Protocol is KYC level 0 (ID never required).

Which has more incidents on record?

Lightning Loop has 0 and Maya Protocol has 0 documented incidents in the registry.

More comparisons