Skip to content
NoKYCScore
/
Submit a service

Atomic Mail vs Tuta

It is a trade-off. Tuta has the higher Safety grade (7.3 against 5.5), while Atomic Mail has the higher Privacy grade (6.6 against 6.5).

Atomic Mail

Estonian encrypted email with no phone number and seed-phrase account recovery

Privacy

6.6/ 10

Fair

Safety

5.5/ 10

Fair

No ID mentioned KYC 1 Docs reviewed Full review →

Tuta

German encrypted email and calendar with open-source clients and a free tier

Privacy

6.5/ 10

Fair

Safety

7.3/ 10

Strong

No ID mentioned KYC 1 Docs reviewed Full review →

Side by side

Atomic MailTuta
Category Email Email
KYC policy No ID mentioned No ID mentioned
Custody N/A N/A
Sign-up No account needed No account needed
Open source No Yes
Tor onion address No No
Pay with Card Card, PayPal
Fees Core service free; optional paid plans via Stripe or app stores Not published
Limits Website and mail logs, including IP addresses, kept for up to 7 days Not published
Founded Not published 2011
Jurisdiction Estonia Germany
Incidents on record 0 0
Published tests (180 days) 0 0

Only Atomic Mail

No email needed

Both

No phone neededLegal entity disclosed

Only Tuta

Open source5+ years operating

Where they sit among email

2 2 4 4 6 6 8 8 10 10 PRIVATE AND SAFE SAFE, ASKS MORE PRIVATE, LESS PROVEN PRIVACY GRADE → SAFETY GRADE → Proton Mail Privacy 7.2 · Safety 7.3 Tuta Privacy 6.5 · Safety 7.3 Posteo Privacy 7.8 · Safety 6.5 Onion Mail Privacy 7.4 · Safety 6.5 mailbox Privacy 7.0 · Safety 6.5 Runbox Privacy 6.2 · Safety 6.5 StartMail Privacy 6.2 · Safety 6.5 Mailfence Privacy 5.9 · Safety 6.5 Riseup Mail Privacy 7.2 · Safety 6.0 Disroot Privacy 6.7 · Safety 6.0 LNemail Privacy 8.5 · Safety 5.7 Atomic Mail Privacy 6.6 · Safety 5.5 Mailum Privacy 7.8 · Safety 5.4 CounterMail Privacy 6.4 · Safety 5.0 monocles Privacy 5.8 · Safety 5.0 cock.li Privacy 7.0 · Safety 4.8 NeroMail Privacy 8.4 · Safety 4.6 ghostBox Privacy 6.9 · Safety 4.6
Trade Spend Infrastructure Identity 18 services. Hover or tap a point.

Questions

Is Atomic Mail or Tuta safer?

Tuta has the higher Safety grade: Atomic Mail 5.5, Tuta 7.3, out of 10.

Does Atomic Mail or Tuta require KYC?

Atomic Mail is KYC level 1 (no ID mentioned). Tuta is KYC level 1 (no ID mentioned).

Which has more incidents on record?

Atomic Mail has 0 and Tuta has 0 documented incidents in the registry.

More comparisons